Ruth Marcus at the Washington Post wonders if PowerPoint is a killing app. She’s not the first to note that NASA administrators make decisions — sometimes fatal decisions — on the basis of PowerPoint presentations that mask or misrepresent details. I wrote about Edward Tufte’s Cognitive Style of PowerPoint essay in a previous post. Marcus doesn’t add to many new points, but the column is a sign that an anti-PowerPoint movement may be growing. Here are three paragraphs:

[T]he insidious influence of PowerPoint goes beyond the way it frustrates scientific analysis. The deeper problem with the PowerPointing of America — the PowerPointing of the planet, actually — is that the program tends to flatten the most complex, subtle, even beautiful, ideas into tedious, bullet-pointed bureaucratese.

The most disturbing development in the world of PowerPoint is its migration to the schools — like sex and drugs, at earlier and earlier ages. Now we have second-graders being tutored in PowerPoint. No matter that students who compose at the keyboard already spend more energy perfecting their fonts than polishing their sentences — PowerPoint dispenses with the need to write any sentences at all. Perhaps the politicians who are so worked up about the ill effects of violent video games should turn their attention to PowerPoint instead.

In the meantime, Tufte, who’s now doing consulting work for NASA, has a modest proposal for its new administrator: Ban the use of PowerPoint. Sounds good to me. After all, you don’t have to be a rocket scientist to see the perils of PowerPoint.

tags: cognitive style, dyn, edward tufte, insidious, killer app, nasa, nasa administrators, perils, powerpoint presentations, powerpoint sounds, rocket scientist, ruth marcus

Posted September 15, 2005 by Casey Bisson
Categories: Books, Movies, Music, Politics & Controversy, Technology. Tags: cognitive style, dyn, edward tufte, insidious, killer app, nasa, nasa administrators, perils, powerpoint presentations, powerpoint sounds, rocket scientist, ruth marcus.

7 Comments

Comments RSS TrackBack Identifier URI

Leave a comment

Name (required)

Mail (will not be published) (required)

Website

 

User contributed tags for this post:

funny powerpoint (1688) - funny ppt (1401) - funny powerpoints (479) - powerpoint funny (410) - ppt funny (341) - fun ppt (263) - funny powerpoint presentations (262) - fun powerpoints (178) - fun powerpoint (176) - scary powerpoints (175) - powerpoint fun (171) - scary powerpoint (163) - funny powerpoint presentation (159) - funny power point (143) - funny pictures ppt (110) - crazy powerpoints (88) - all (87) - scary ppt (62) - funny power points (62) - funny presentations (50) - funny power point presentation (43) - funny (42) - crazy powerpoint (41) - power point funny (41) - ppt fun (38) - scary powerpoint presentations (38) - NASA Erth (37) - funny pictures for presentations (34) - powerpoint (33) - fun (31) - funny funny power point presentations (30) - funny picture ppt (29) - funny ppt images (29) - POwerpoint presentation funny (27) - funniest powerpoint in the world (26) - fun powerpoint presentations (25) - fun powerpoint pictures (25) - funny presentations power point (24) - fun power point (23) - funny pics on powerpoint (22) - funny archive powerpoint (22) - funny images for powerpoint presentations (21) - funny pictures for ppt presentations (20) - girls ppt (20) - funny photos in powerpoint (19) - powerpoint funny pictures (19) - funny pictures presentations powerpoint (18) - funniest ppt (17) - funny ppt presentations (16) - powerpoint funny pics (15) - Crazy PowerPoint presentations (14) - crazy ppt (14) - funny pics and funny powerpoints (14) - funny power point presentations (13) - funny ppts (13) - funny powerpoint and picture (13) - powerpoint funny images (13) - powerpoint on drugs (12) - ppt pics (12) - ppt funny presentations (12) - scary katrina pictures (12) - powerpoint pics (12) - powerpoint ban (12) -