A while ago I reported on the Pew Internet Project’s November 2005 report on increased use of search engines. Here’s what I had to say at the time:
On an average day, about 94 million American adults use the internet; 77% will use email, 63% will use a search engine.
Among all the online activities tracked, including chatting and IMing, reading blogs or news, banking, and buying, not one of them includes searching a library OPAC.
Walt Crawford properly took me to task, noting:
The report that’s downloadable does show that people aren’t being asked an open-ended “what did you do on the Internet today?” question. They’re being asked to respond to a list. If “searching a library OPAC” isn’t on the list, it is absolutely guaranteed not to be in the results.
It’s taken me some time, but I’m finally following up on that point. The question seems to revolve around how the list of activities was generated, and to answer it I contacted project director Lee Rainie. Lee explained that the intent of the project and the surveys is to help us understand how people use the internet and does not consider other activities. Regarding the list of ten online activities in this survey, he noted that it was a list he chose as “an illustrative list, rather than comprehensive list.”
Lee was careful to emphasize the way he values libraries and wanted to be clear that though the Project has tracked 90 online activities in its many surveys, they haven’t yet asked internet users about their use of online library services. I don’t know if it was just because I was asking the questions, or if he’s been thinking about this for some time, but he did suggest that the project might include library-related questions in a future study.
I was putting Lee in a tough spot, as the real question we want him to answer is something along the lines of “did the survey not include questions about online library usage because it’s statistically insignificant or was it an oversight?” Lee is a smart guy, smart enough not to answer that — smart enough to avoid stepping into our internal debates — so the following is based on my continued research into the question, not my conversation with him.
As it turns out, while much of the most interesting data in the November 20 2005 report comes from the project’s phone survey, the report uses data from comScore to support those phone survey results. While Walt is right about the phone survey, the comScore data doesn’t appear subject to those limitations:
The comScore data cited in this report come from comScore Media Metrix, an internet audience measurement service that uses a massive cross-section of more than 1.5 million U.S. consumers who have given comScore explicit permission to confidentially capture their browsing and transaction behavior, including online and offline purchasing.
In a comment to my previous post, KateZ expressed some concern that the comScore data was only tracking top search engines; comScore offers many reports based on their usage tracking, the qSearch report is a keyword optimization tool and doesn’t reflect the full breadth of data harvested by the company. It doesn’t answer the question on its own, but can we not assume that a company that makes is business by tracking the every online activity of its research subjects would investigate any library-related activity if such activity was significant enough to reveal trends in consumer interest or behavior?
Elsewhere, in the PIP’s August 11 2004 report on The Internet and Daily Life, we find some detailed insights on how those phone survey questions are selected:
To assemble a good list of activities, we followed insights gained from previous research and divided online activities into four categories: information seeking; communications; transactions; and entertainment. We chose several examples for each category. These examples are not meant to cover all kinds of activities, but rather to represent everyday tasks and typical recreations that Americans enjoy. We chose activities that would broadly represent what the Internet has to offer, that would resonate with a broad audience, and that would tap into our understanding of the Internet use gained from our past research. Recognizing, of course, our choice of particular activities might influence the findings, we tried to observe the specific but then draw generalizations from our observations.
And in the November 2 2005 report on Teen Content Creators and Consumers, we learn that the project uses focus groups and small surveys with open ended questions to help shape their research and larger surveys. In that case:
Four focus groups were also conducted with a total of 38 high school and middle school students.
…teens took an online survey of multiple choice, open-ended and short-answer-style questions…
Full details on page 25 of the PDF.
So, I can’t really offer the answers we all want, but my gut feeling is that if library usage was a statistically significant activity for American internet users, the Pew Internet folks would have picked up on it and asked more detailed questions.
Sadly, I’ve been so slow to followup on all this that it may not matter anymore. OCLC released their Perceptions of Libraries and Information Resources report in early December. The report revealed that patrons are generally happier using search engines than their libraries when asked to rate both in terms of volume, quality, speed, and overall experience.
This is scary to some, but good news to the libraries that are willing to take advantage of it. It means the tools, the access, and the information literacy are all coming together for our patrons. Now it’s just up to us to participate.
I’ll be talking about this in my ALA Midwinter presentation, see you in San Antonio.
search engines, library, libraries, library usage, online library, online libraries, online activities, pew internet project, pew internet and american life project, internet, internet usage, online behavior, lib20, library20, library 2.0, library evolution, search engine, search engine use, web searching
Related:
Posted January 8, 2006 by Casey
Categories: Libraries & Networked Information. Tags: internet, internet usage, lib20, libraries, library, library 2.0, library evolution, library usage, library20, online activities, online behavior, online libraries, online library, pew internet and american life project, pew internet project, search engine, search engine use, search engines, web searching.
No Comments
No comments yet.
Comments RSS
TrackBack Identifier URI
Leave a comment
User contributed tags for this post:
library vs internet (48) - library versus internet (22) - internet vs library (21) - libraries vs search engines (9) - internet usage vs library use survey (9) - Internet versus library (7) - internet vs library debate (6) - Library Vs Search Engine (5) - library vs internet research (5) - Libraries vs Internet (5) - Library vs search engines (5) - Libraries versus Internet (4) - online library versus ground library (4) - online research vs library (4) - search a debate (4) - online research versus library research (4) - libraries v internet (4) - Library vs Online search (4) - search engine vs library (3) - library versus internet use (3) - research online vs library (3) - internet vs library questionnaire (3) - online library vs on-ground library (3) - search engines debate (3) - internet vs and library vs research (3) - Online research vs traditional library (3) - searching 1 questionnaire (3) - google versus library (3) - online research versus traditional library (3) - Library vs Google (3) - internet (3) - library vs internet questionnaire (3) - online versus on ground library (3) - usage of internet vs usage of library(Questionnaire) (2) - Library versus the Internet debate (2) - Americans internet search vs library (2) - online research versus going to a library (2) - library vs internet searches (2) - library vs (2) - online libraries vs ground libraries (2) - search vs research (2) - online research vs traditional library research (2) - online search vs library (2) - library versus internet research (2) - advantages of researching internet versus library (2) - survey questions web usage for online research (2) - online library v ground library (2) - Library Search Vs Internet Search (2) - sex farmer com sex search engine (2) - opac versus (2) - debate library versus internet (2) - traditional library vs online library (2) - Multiple Choice Questions of Search engine (2) - Library Use versus Internet Use (2) - search engine vs libraries (2) - google internet usage questionnaire (2) - internet vs books (2) - Internet vs book (2) - online research versus in the library (2) - questionair about internet (2) - trends in library usage (2) - online research versus library (2) - research vs search (2) - library versus internet google (2) - consumer goes to library vs using internet for research (2) - internet vs library research (2) - internet versus library usage (2) - Online Libraries vs libraries (2) - online search vs library search (2) - library vs internet surveys (2) - library use vs internet use (2) - library versus the internet (2) - search engine vs library searching (2) - library vs the internet (2) - internet use compared to library (2) - online search versus library (2) - online research vs library research (2) - internet versus library research survey (2) - search engine versus the library (2) - search engine versus library (2) - internet searching vs library (2) - Study in Internet vs Library (2) - online library vs ground library (2) - debate search engines (2) - search engine usage versus library usage (2) - internet vs library as research tool (2) - internet usage library usage public libraries (2) - online research versus library research results (2) - search engine survey questionnaire (2) - Google vs library (2) - debate search (2) - library versus online research (2) - library usage vs internet searching (2) - library online vs search engine (2) - library usage vs internet usage (2) - walt crawford library 2 0 (2) - online library verus on ground library (2) - online questionnaire on search engines (2) - walt lishost org (2) - survey questionnaire about internet vs library (2) - online behavior tracking comscore (2) - library searching Internet searching (2) - oclc research (2) - opac (2) - online research than traditional library (1) - internet versus the library (1) - online versus on-ground library. (1) - Questionnaire on searching information in the internet (1) - search engine vs internet usage (1) - interntet based research vs lirary research (1) - Six Weapons of Influence questionnaire (1) - Questionair for library (1) - search engine vs. library (1) - traditional versus online libraries (1) - library online research versus book research (1) - library questionnaires (1) - questionnaire on t v vs internet (1) - Book Vs Internet Debate (1) - comparison of time to search on internet vs time to res (1) - Library research vs the Internet (1) - library research versus internet research (1) - debate books online vs books (1) - advantages of an on-line library versus an on ground li (1) - library online search versus traditional library (1) - search tool library vs online (1) - ??? tap (1) - to investigate library versus search engine (1) - online library vs library (1) - libraries vs the internet (1) - information from libraries or internet wikipedia versus (1) - consumers use library versus internet for research (1) - traditional library versus library online search (1) - tracking library usage (1) - internet vs library questionnaires (1) - library reference transactions vs google searches (1) - internet use vs library use (1) - google vs library research (1) - reasearch online vs reasearch in library (1) - a library compared to the internet (1) - library research versus online research (1) - open ended questions for cell phone debate (1) - questionnaire for internet users searching (1) - high school library search engines (1) - questionair libraries (1) - online library v on-ground library (1) - research on internet vs the library (1) - library versus web search (1) - What are the advantages of ground libraries verus on li (1) - internet or library debate (1) - reseach on the internet versus a traditional library (1) -
