Arthur Schopenhauer is suggested to have said:

Every truth passes through three stages before it is recognized. In the first it is ridiculed, in the second it is violently opposed, in the third is regarded as self-evident.

If the reaction to Karen Calhoun’s report to the Library of Congress on The Changing Nature of the Catalog and its Integration with Other Discovery Tools is any guide, libraries are stuck firmly in the second stage.

The most recent denial comes from an Inside Higher Ed story titled “Calling Melvil Dewey” which strikes out at both Calhoun’s report and the recent cataloging changes by the LoC.

My comment there remarks:

Among all the negative and alarmist coverage I’ve seen of Calhoun’s report and the LoC’s proposed cataloging changes (this included), I have yet to see anybody refute the premise or suggest a workable alternative.

Our patrons value our institutions in many ways, but amidst budget and technological pressures that threaten to eliminate libraries, our blind insistence on “business as usual” isn’t one of them.

Really, though, how are we supposed to take seriously an article that tells us “most librarians rely on the Library of Congress cataloguing copy pretty much wholesale,” then sounds the alarm at Calhoun’s suggestion that copy cataloging be streamlined? And, about that Dewey reference in the title? On the one hand the man was an unabashed progressive reformer of libraries, on the other he’s said to have held very repressive social values. Which side of Dewey is being invoked here?

reform, progress, library of congress, LoC, Melvil Dewey, Karen Calhoun, series authority records, cataloging changes, library, libraries, lib20, library 2.0, discovery tools

Posted July 30, 2006 by Casey Bisson
Categories: Libraries & Networked Information, Politics & Controversy. Tags: cataloging changes, discovery tools, Karen Calhoun, lib20, libraries, library, library 2.0, library of congress, loc, Melvil Dewey, progress, reform, series authority records.

2 Comments

Comments RSS TrackBack Identifier URI

Leave a comment

Name (required)

Mail (will not be published) (required)

Website

 

User contributed tags for this post:

WWW GEO TV COM (160) - www geo tv for truth (104) - geo tv com (62) - ro 89 com (46) - www Geo TV com Pk (44) - geo tv com pk (28) - www geo tv (28) - Jeo tv (25) - www geo/tv com (20) - www ro 89 com (19) - GEO TV FOR TRUTH (18) - ro 89 (18) - WWW EARTH TV COM (16) - WWW GEO NEWS COM (14) - truth (13) - jeo tv com (11) - www.geotv/com (9) - www.geotv.com.pk (9) - www geo tv truth (9) - geotv.com.pk (8) - www pink teen com (8) - www geo tv pakistan (7) - geo news com (7) - time passing quote (7) - www.geotv.com (6) - www jeo tv (6) - www jeo tv com (6) - WWW Pink tv com (6) - www.ro 89.com (5) - ro 89.com (5) - WWW 3 PIC COM (5) - www pakistani stage show (5) - www.jeo.tv.pk (5) - WWW GEO NEWS (5) - two truth (4) - www geo new (4) - www geotv com pk (4) - www.jeo.tv.com (4) - site:maisonbisson com www geo tv com (4) - www geo for truth (4) - www geo pakistan (4) - jeo.tv (4) - www-geo-tv-com (4) - WWW PINK TV (4) - jeo tv com pk (4) - www geo tv ro (4) - www.jeo.tv (4) - www geo tv for the truth (3) - www.pakistan geotv.com (3) - www geo news tv (3) - www pakistani stage (3) - www 69 tv com (3) - jeo.tv.pk (3) - www stage 6 com (3) - www ro 89 (3) - geo tv truth (3) - www g e o tv for truth (3) - www.jeo tv.com (3) - geo tv com pk truth (3) - www.pakistanstag.com (3) - STAGE 2 OF LOCS (3) - www.pakistanistageshow (3) - www.jeo tv.com.pk (3) - WWW 69 TV (3) - www ro 89.com (3) - inside higher ed (2) - MALIK IMTIAZ AWAN (2) - www.geotv@com (2) - jeo.tv.com (2) - schopenhauer (2) - geo tv news com (2) - stage two (2) - pk stage show (2) - the two truth (2) - geo tv ro (2) - pakistani teen,com (2) - the first stage is ridiculed the second stage (2) - www.jeo.tv.com pk (2) - www ro tv com (2) - pakistanstag (2) - pakistanstag.com (2) -