There’s an interesting discussion going at LibDev about what our ILSs are. It all started with a discussion of what role XML and webservices could/should play with ILS/catalogs, but a comment reminded us that Vendor’s decisions about adding new features to products that have been around for 20 or 30 years sometimes edge towards lock-in. I replied offering Flickr as an example of a vendor that’s been successful in part because of their open APIs.

Then David Walker made the point that most ILS were built as inventory systems in the days long before Google showed us that search and retrieval was a separate issue.

The problem is that we have long mistaken these systems for a search and retrieval tool. That is really only a secondary (at best) feature of any ILS, and so it should come as no surprise to us that [they leave] much, much to be desired in that area.

David’s point is almost inarguable. Entirely inarguable, except that electronic sources represent a growing region of our information landscape while the relative number of non-electronic resources inventoried in the ILS shrinks. Unless the ILS evolves, the only items we’ll need to inventory are our preserved resources and archives, and ILSs aren’t very good at that either.

tags: david walker, electronic resources, electronic sources, flickr, google, ils, integrated library system, inventory system, libdev, library system, search and retrieval, search help

Posted July 25, 2005 by Casey Bisson
Categories: Libraries & Networked Information. Tags: david walker, electronic resources, electronic sources, flickr, google, ils, integrated library system, inventory system, libdev, library system, search and retrieval, search help.

No Comments

No comments yet.

Comments RSS TrackBack Identifier URI

Leave a comment

Name (required)

Mail (will not be published) (required)

Website

 

User contributed tags for this post:

ILS inventory (16) - about (14) - ils search (5) - inventory retrieval (4) - google ils (4) - سک30 (4) - داستان سک30 (4) - ILS INVENTORY SYSTEM (3) - ils part search (3) - ILS system (2) - Goole Library inventory system (2) - goole bangla sex (2) - Search ils (2) - google hearth system (2) - all (2) - inventory retrieval system (2) - google erth system (2) - girl سک30 (1) - ils inventory report (1) - mysql movie inventory (1) - سك30 (1) - inventory library system (1) - library inventory system (1) - search and retrieval vs. findability (1) - inventory in a library system (1) - inventory system of library (1) - inventory system (1) - inventory retrieval systems (1) - inventory database search retrieval systems (1) - ILS search system (1) - ILS INVENTORY SEARCH (1) - ils search retrieval (1) - search retrieval system (1) - archive retrieval tools inventory (1) - http://www google com/ (1) - Inventory system hacks (1) - wwwsixfilm@.com (1) -