A Patron’s Perspective On Library 2.0

My friend Joe Monninger is perhaps a library’s favorite patron. He’s an avid reader who depends on his public library for books and audiobooks and DVDs, and as a writer and professor he depends on the services of the university library. But he doesn’t work in libraries, and though he listens patiently to my work stories, he doesn’t really care about the politics or internal struggles we face.

That said, I’m reprinting here the full text of his recent column for the Valley News, a paper serving Hanover New Hampshire and other upper Connecticut River valley communities. He’s discussing the challenge we face from the perspective of an interested customer.

Here it is:

A quiet revolution is taking place among university libraries.

It’s a revolution that will speak to the function of libraries in general and, more specifically, to the culture surrounding reading. With Google talking about putting the world’s libraries on line, university libraries, to everyone’s surprise and amazement, have become the battleground upon which the nature of books and reading will be fought.

Here’s why. At Plymouth State University’s Lamson Library, where I teach, approximately 15% of the library’s collection is circulated. Flipped the other way, that number means 85% of the library’s collection sits untouched year after year, collecting dust and taking up space. Those numbers are about on par with other university libraries across the nation. While circulation is stagnant in hard-backed books, the library has never been more active. The University’s Reading and Writing Center is housed in the library, and the planning board for the library has just completed designs for bringing in a coffee shop, similar to Starbuck’s, onto the library’s ground floor. The entire building now is wireless, meaning you can take your laptop into the coffee shop, drink a cup of Joe, and surf the library at UCLA, or the Sorbonne, or Harvard — at least in principle. You can also pop in a DVD and watch a movie, or you can download music from any number of sources, grabbing rap, jazz, or classical as the mood strikes you. And nobody, by the way, is going to worry overmuch if you happen to spill a little of your bagel on a book you’ve borrowed. The former sacredness of library collections, governed by the severe librarians who served as priests, is finally being deflated.

The culture of books, and university life, is changing so rapidly it’s hard to keep pace. To give a small example outside of academia, consider the recent offering by The New Yorker Magazine. For $100, an extraordinarily modest item on a library budget, you can purchase the entire archives of The New Yorker from its inception to the most recent issues. All of The New Yorkers. All of the ads, cartoons, covers, and so on. Now think of the man and woman power it required, not to mention the space, to house the archives of The New Yorker in a typical library. Anyone who has felt the weight of a well meaning aunt’s gift subscription to National Geographic will understand immediately. All of those odd journals university libraries are compelled to have on hand for “accreditation†will soon give way to electronic versions, and they will be accessed, naturally, from the coffee shop.

Older folks — not to mention more stately librarians — are not always pleased by this turn of events. Not long ago I had reason to research back issues of The New York Times. At Lamson we still have the microfilm doohickeys, the one that make you thread the tape in, spin it on a spool, and little by little, after maneuvering, you can find what you are looking for. During the course of my research I discovered Dartmouth College has The New York Times from the Civil War forward on computer. In three key strokes I could usually find what I was searching for at Dartmouth. When I mentioned it to a librarian at Plymouth, she said, “Well, that’s fine and good, but what if the electricity goes out?†I didn’t have the heart to point out that a blackout would also finish work on the microfilm machine. Nor did I suggest we probably wouldn’t be doing research in a darkened library.

What she meant, though she couldn’t articulate it at that moment, is that she has faith in books. She has faith in rows and rows of knowledge compiled carefully, ready to lend a hand if someone requires it. And doubtless she also has affection for the smell and feel of books, the lovely portability and companionable weight of them opened on one’s lap. The proposition that books have become something other, something different, is disturbing to her and many others.

In academia, perhaps more than most places, we are struggling with the nature of books and publishing. When a colleague “goes up†for promotion, she or he must present a portfolio of the work accomplished before the review period. That work is then reviewed by a committee of peers to judge its acceptability and gravitas. That sounds pompous, so let’s call it a job review. But now, with electronic publication available to anyone who wants to take advantage of it, the nature of “a book†has come under scrutiny. Is a blog a book? Is a poem sent to a website a “published†poem? How about if one uses a site like LuLu.com to self-publish a book — is that as intellectually viable as a book brought out by an editor and a publishing company? Are they two sides of the same coin, or is publishing a book with a traditional publisher a more solid credential? If one writes about one’s travel to Singapore on a blog, is it the equivalent of publishing a piece in The Atlantic Monthly? Are we judging the publisher, or the item published?

Younger people, naturally, find all of this equivocating silly. They know where they are going to look for information, and it sure as heck isn’t the library — at least not the library as it currently exists. In a healthy way, perhaps, they don’t make distinctions about information. They use it, then move on. Sometimes that gets them into trouble when they are not discerning enough about the internet source of information, but that’s a relatively small price to pay for the rapidity and ease of availability. Ask a teenager what’s playing at the movies, and she or he will go to the net to find out, not the local paper or phone book. Ask him or her to write something about Hamlet, and they are going to Google Hamlet and get back to you. The quaint trip to the library in the roadster with Betty Sue — and a malt afterward — is doubtless a thing of the long past.

But the rewards for the newer libraries are going to be fabulous. Even now, the typical homeowner with internet access can have all of Shakespeare, Tolstoy, Dickens, Austen, and on and on and on from the comfort of their computer screen. They can have virtual access to all music, all film, all maps, all magazines, all newspapers. What will change, what is already changing, is the architecture of a library. Instead of building with brick and mortar, libraries will build electronic extensions in homes, in hospitals, in airports. Libraries will be with us day and night, always available, always open. We will carry them with us in our briefcases and on our vacations. Library walls will come down, and those rows of books, still lovely, still beautiful, will take on new life.

library, libraries, library 2.0, user centered design, opinion, customer, user, outside opinion, unsolicited advice, organizational evolution, evolution of libraries

17 Comments

  1. Comment by Jenny Levine on December 14, 2005 12:24 am

    Thanks for sharing this, Casey!

  2. Comment by jessamyn on December 17, 2005 5:41 pm

    Hey that’s my local paper! I don’t know how I missed that, thanks for posting this.

  3. Trackback by blogwithoutalibrary.net on December 18, 2005 10:42 am

    library 2.0 - a patronÂ’s perspective

    YouÂ’re probably already well up on the theorizing and navel-gazing going on in the biblioblogosphere about Library 2.0. ThereÂ’s been plenty of great discussion. My favourite slice? This post by Casey Bisson on a patronÂ’s perspective on Library 2.0. …

  4. Trackback by Isaak's Thoughts on December 20, 2005 8:23 am

    Isaak’s Links

    A PatronÂ’s Perspective on Library 2.0
    A patronÂ’s look at the changes that are happening in libraries around the world and how it will affect the physical structure of libraries. A good read.
    (via MaisonBission.com)

  5. Comment by Michael Stephens on January 2, 2006 10:21 am

    Great stuff! Thanks for posting this.

  6. Comment by Dwight on January 3, 2006 12:05 pm

    Casey, thanks for sharing this, Joe, very well written! This article speaks to the very nature of the changes we face in adapting to new technologies and how we get our information. You hit many nails on the head. I especially liked your final thought: ‘Library walls will come down, and those rows of books, still lovely, still beautiful, will take on new life.’

    Yes indeed!

  7. Trackback by Tame The Web: Libraries and Technology on January 4, 2006 9:49 pm

    A Patron’s Perspective On Library 2.0

    Via Maison Bisson (Who also wrote about L2 here.)

    A reprint of an incredible article written by a library user:

    The University’s Reading and Writing Center is housed in the library, and the planning board for the library has just completed designs for bringing in a coffee shop, similar to Starbuck’s, onto the library’s ground floor. The entire building now is wireless, meaning you can take your laptop into the coffee shop, drink a cup of Joe, and surf the library at UCLA, or the Sorbonne, or Harvard  at least in principle. You can also pop in a DVD and watch a movie, or you can download music from any number of sources, grabbing rap, jazz, or classical as the mood strikes you. And nobody, by the way, is going to worry overmuch if you happen to spill a little of your bagel on a book you’ve borrowed. The former sacredness of library collections, governed by the severe librarians who served as priests, is finally being deflated.

    Amen!

  8. Pingback by Infomancy » Blog - Book - Blog on January 5, 2006 4:14 pm

    [...] Michael Stephens of Tame the Web provided a link to MaisonBisson’s reprint of a friend’s newspaper article about Library 2.0 (L2) from a patron’s perspective. Michael, focuses on the academic connections in the article, but I was more drawn to the author’s view of the upcoming academic customers - our current high school students. Joe Monninger, described as “a library’s favorite patron” is talking about the quibbling in academia over the definitions of “book” and “publish” as related to things like LuLu.com and blogging. Then he backs up a bit and looks at more reasons why I keep suggesting that we need to move beyond “book.” Younger people, naturally, find all of this equivocating silly. They know where they are going to look for information, and it sure as heck isn’t the library  at least not the library as it currently exists. In a healthy way, perhaps, they don’t make distinctions about information. They use it, then move on. Sometimes that gets them into trouble when they are not discerning enough about the internet source of information, but that’s a relatively small price to pay for the rapidity and ease of availability. Ask a teenager what’s playing at the movies, and she or he will go to the net to find out, not the local paper or phone book. Ask him or her to write something about Hamlet, and they are going to Google Hamlet and get back to you. The quaint trip to the library in the roadster with Betty Sue  and a malt afterward  is doubtless a thing of the long past. (Joe Monninger via MaisonBisson) [...]

  9. Pingback by lauren’s library blog » Blog Archive » preparing for Library 2.0 on January 6, 2006 10:18 pm

    [...] The ongoing conversation between Casey Bisson at Maison Bisson, Michael Stephens at Tame the Web, and Christopher Harris at Infomancy got me thinking about our clients. [...]

  10. Trackback by Out of the Jungle on January 6, 2006 10:44 pm

    A PatronÂ’s Perspective On Library 2.0

    From MaisonBisson.com: “A PatronÂ’s Perspective On Library 2.0″

  11. Pingback by Infomancy » SL2.0: Synthesis 2.0 on January 10, 2006 3:39 pm

    [...] Library 2.0 - Some Background There has been a lot to read about the idea of Library 2.0 (L2) over a few short months. Over the past week, though, a couple of pieces started to solidify enough to allow better contemplation. I was especially drawn to an article from an academic about academic libraries that I commented on last week. The author, Joe Monninger, isn’t writing about L2, but does notice something that I think is critical for school librarians to think about: younger students may not see libraries as information sources. This isn’t because of some Library 1.0 thing, or a failure by libraries or librarians, but rather because of the changing nature of information and education. [...]

  12. Comment by Edward Vielmetti on January 17, 2006 1:12 am

    very nice, thanks for posting this.

    i think libraries have a lot to learn from listening to their patrons.

  13. Pingback by Educause on Future of Libraries « MaisonBisson.com on January 18, 2006 8:10 am

    [...] The editorial continues, but I couldn’t help but see some similarity between this piece and the Patron’s Perspective on Library 2.0 piece I ran previously. [...]

  14. Pingback by Malins WP-blogg » links for 2006-01-23 on January 23, 2006 5:22 pm

    [...] A Patron’s Perspective On Library 2.0 « MaisonBisson.com (tags: classification library technology library2.0 web2.0) [...]

  15. Pingback by Plinius » SK 9/06 on February 26, 2006 2:53 am

    [...] Resten finner du hos Casey Bisson, en underfundig amerikansk bibliotekar. [...]

  16. Comment by Jeremy on March 6, 2006 10:41 pm

    I wanted to read your article, but I can’t, because there’s a Google ad covering it. Get rid of the ads or some people won’t be able to actually get to your content. :)

  17. Pingback by Speaking My Language « MaisonBisson.com on March 21, 2006 9:30 pm

    [...] My friend Joe wrote: Younger people, naturally, find all of this equivocating silly. They know where they are going to look for information, and it sure as heck isn’t the library — at least not the library as it currently exists. In a healthy way, perhaps, they don’t make distinctions about information. They use it, then move on. [...]

Comments RSS TrackBack Identifier URI

Leave a comment

 

User contributed tags for this post:

sexs woman (62) - woman sexs (43) - cartoon sexs (41) - changing perspective cartoons (40) - joe monninger (37) - hotsex net (36) - sex tv1 (31) - www.woldsex.com (29) - sex tv1.pl (28) - Joseph Monninger (28) - sexs cartoon (26) - Cartoon Changing perspective (22) - library 2 0 (21) - sexs carton (19) - sexs (19) - sexs shop (18) - www.hotsex.net (18) - cartoons changing perspective (17) - cartoon film sexs (17) - SEXS SHOP COM (17) - dvd SexS (15) - maison bisson (15) - changing perspective cartoon (14) - sexs com (14) - library (13) - sexs net (13) - sexs com net (13) - WOLDSEX.COM (11) - sexs karton (11) - KARTON SEXS (10) - sexgirl sk (10) - www.sex tv1.pl (10) - patron sex (10) - perspective cartoon (10) - carton sexs (9) - patron vs customer (9) - school library 2 0 (9) - Timothy Treadwell cartoon (8) - all (8) - casey bisson plymouth state (8) - hotsex (8) - library 2 0 academic libraries (7) - tv1.pl (7) - sex.tv1 (7) - sex tv1 pl (7) - sexs spill (6) - Patron 2 0 (6) - cartoons sexs (6) - web 2 0 academic libraries (6) - perspective of the structure of library (6) - evolution of libraries (6) - librarians (6) - academic library 2 0 (6) - www.sex.tv1.pl (6) - cartoon on changing perspective (6) - Casey Bisson plymouth (6) - changing perspective (5) - my (5) - sex tv 1 pl (5) - libraries gotten rid of New York times on microfilm online only (5) - changing perspectives cartoons (5) - change in perspective cartoon (5) - sexs move (5) - bisson library (5) - cartoons on changing perspective (5) - TIMOTHY TREADWELL HIGH SCHOOL (4) - Maison blog grizzly (4) - sexs hos (4) - story on changing perspective (4) - 2 point perspective (4) - timothy tredwell national geographic (4) - sexgirl move (4) - Meaning of Patron (4) - maison perspective (4) - library 2 0 academic (4) - cartoon about changing perspective (4) - MaisonBission (4) - maison blog grizzly man blog (4) - what is a patron (4) - how to write a perspective paper (4) - www.pinkword.com (4) - library2 0 (4) - sexs education for teenager kartoon (4) - library2 0 patron (4) - cartoons on perspective (4) - sexs cartoons (4) - new yorker magazine subscription (4) - cartoons with change in perspective (4) - change perspective cartoon (4) - changing perspective newspaper articles (4) - sex (4) - cartoon sexs com (3) - xxx librarians (3) - 5934088617522 (3) - perspective cartoons (3) - sex.TV1.PL (3) - Academic Library cartoon (3) - changing perspectives cartoon (3) - cartoon changing perspectives (3) - library 2 0 map (3) - arabic woman sex (3) - cartoons with changing perspective (3) - patron de maison (3) - (patron or patrons) and (center or centered) and (library or libraries) (3) - perspective of library (3) - library patron blog (3) - cartoon change perspective (3) - cartoons on changing perspectives (3) - maisonbission com (3) - sex woman (3) - maison en perspective (3) - tv1 pl (3) - changing perspective newspaper article (3) - ten point perspective (3) - top vedio library (3) - maison bisson timothy treadwell film (2) - newspaper article about timothy tredwell (2) - quiet library cartoon (2) - How to write a perspective (2) - coffee shops in academic libraries (2) - WWW HOTSEX NET (2) - plymouth university casey bisson (2) - SEXS FILM AND DVD (2) - patron de perspective (2) - articles on libraries new yorker magazine (2) - library website connecticut (2) - Joe Monninger Plymouth State (2) - poem on changing perspective (2) - sexs mood (2) - library 2 0 academic library (2) - cartoon sex move (2) - new yorker grizzly cartoons (2) - the new yorker map of NY perspective (2) - joe maisonbisson (2) - what is the meaning of patron (2) - change perspective article (2) - cartoons on changing self (2) - library 2 0 publishers (2) - www.hotsex,net (2) - what comes under the classification of customer perspec (2) - building library 2 0 academic (2) - library 2 0 indian perspective (2) - cartoon Library 2 0 (2) - library 2 0 an academics perspective (2) - a patron (2) - cartoons about library patrons (2) - cartoons sexs at school (2) - hotsex cartoon (2) - library 2 0 cartoon (2) - scholl sexs com (2) -