
I’m not sure who Robin Harris is, but he’s mighty sure home RAID won’t fly. He’s just so certain that consumers are stupider than him and that vendors’ imaginations are as limited as his. And if Harris was right, we’d probably still be using 8088 microprocessors and getting by on less than a megabyte of RAM, because “nobody needs more than 640K.â€
Too bad then that Data Robotics’s Drobo seems to do everything Harris says home RAID can’t. Actually, it seems to do some incredibly complex things under the hood, but Cali Lewis demonstrates that all we have to do is pop drives in. You can put in one to four drives and they don’t have to be the same capacity (really). You can add drives and expand storage without having to reformat. You don’t have to chose what kind of RAID you need. And if a disk fails, all you do is replace the drive with the flashing light next to it. Drobo keeps working despite the failed disk (though slower, and with less redundancy), and automatically rebuilds the array when you pop in a new drive. Scott Beale/Laughing Squid likes his.
It’s pretty easy to guess that if you have only two drives in there, it’ll do RAID 1. And if you have three or four drives, it’ll do RAID 5. But, let’s say you start with two (RAID 1) and add a third: it’ll seamlessly remap the data into a RAID 5. Who knows how fast it is, but how fast does it need to be? (Thomas Hawk says the new version does 50MB/s reads) I need storage for my photo library. I need big and reliable, I’ll pass on fast if it means I can have it cheap.
And that’s the thing. $350 gets you the original Drobo with USB2 ($500 for FireWire 800/USB2 model). You’ll have to add disks, but you can get 750GB SATA drives for under $100, and 1TB drives are getting close to $150 (and it’s not like you can’t put 750s in it now and upgrade to 2TB drives later). You can pick up simple 1TB external drives for under $250, but then you have to worry about losing everything because a single disk failed. (And are you really going to back up that 1TB music/video collection? Really? Where?) Anne de Haas says it changed her life and calls it ridiculously easy to use.
And if that isn’t cool enough, the DroboShare NAS accessory will make it shareable on the network (NAS, duh), but also run BitTorrent servers or other exciting stuff. DroboSpace is the hopeful hub for hacking on this.
Where have I been for the past year since this was released? I want.
Posted August 27, 2008 by Casey Bisson
Categories: Technology. Tags: Data Robotics, disk, disks, Drobo, easy, hard drives, raid, storage.
5 Comments
Comments RSS
TrackBack Identifier URI
User contributed tags for this post:
drobo hacks (110) - drobo ssd (76) - drobo alternative (60) - drobo hack (44) - drobo encryption (39) - drobo raid (29) - open source drobo (27) - drobo (24) - SSD Drobo (23) - hacking drobo (21) - drobo hacking (19) - diy drobo (18) - hack drobo (14) - Drobo with SSD (11) - drobo open source (10) - SSD in drobo (9) - drobo clone (9) - drobo opensource (7) - drobo pro alternative (7) - home raid (7) - encrypting drobo (7) - Drobo RAID 5 (6) - drobo cheap (6) - cheap drobo (6) - best home raid (6) - encryption on drobo (6) - drobo pro performance (5) - drobo and SSD (5) - how does drobo raid work (5) - drobo blog (5) - best home raid drive mac (4) - encrypt drobo (4) - drobo or RAID (4) - drobohacks (4) - hacking the drobo (4) - cheap home raid (4) - drobo raid type (4) - www.drob.com raid (3) - diy drobo pro (3) - drobo comparison (3) - drobo 3 (3) - drobo diy (3) - drobo centos (3) - best 1TB drives for drobo (3) - solaris drobo (3) - cheap drobo alternative (3) - drobo pro slow (3) - drobo pro alternatives (3) - drobo solaris (3) - drobo encrypt (3) - home raid 1 (3) - nas drobo alternative (3) - opensource drobo (3) - drobo RAID 1 (3) - best hard drive for use with Drobo (3) - wwwbbcurdu.com (3) - anne de haas (3) - raid z drobo (3) - raid 5 vs drobo (3) - drobo support solid state drives (3) - home raid storage (3) - alternative for drobo pro (2) - drobo for home use (2) - easy home raid storage (2) - best home raid solution (2) - opensource drobo like raid (2) - drobo pro encryption (2) - 8 disk drobo (2) - anything else like drobo (2) - can I put only 2 drives in a drobo (2) - logging in with home = / raid config (2) - raid like drobo (2) - diy raid1 time capsue (2) - best drobo alternative (2) - ssd on drobo (2) - alternatives to drobo (2) - best raid home (2) - drobopro alternatives (2) - cheaper alternative to drobo (2) - open source drobo clone (2) - time capsule raid (2) - RAID DROBO (2) - drobo pro hack (2) - drobo like raid (2) - cheapest drobo (2) - drobo work with ssd (2) - ssd in a drobo (2) - raid easy like drobo but less expensive (2) - diy drobo raid (2) - drobo pro NAS (2) - best raid for home (2) - ssd drives in drobo (2) - drobo vs (2) - drobo vs raid 5 (2) - drobo pro time capsule (2) - open source drobo alternative (2) - drobo and ssd performance (2) - drobo single disk (2) - drobo SSD hard drive for mac 2009 (2) - drobo raid5 (2) - encrypted drobo (2) - does drobo work with ssd (2) - RAID for home use (2) - drobo usb storage solaris (2) - drobo log (2) - drobo cheap drives (2) - drobo home (2) - biggest raid home (2) - best raid for home user disk (2) - drobo drive encryption (2) - drobo disk encryption (2) - Drobo vs Raid 1 (2) - software drobo alternative (2) - raid home user (2) - Drobo vs raid (2) - drobo software raid (2) - drobo robin harris (2) - drobo disk performance (2) - drobo alternative software (2) - drobo 2 comparison (2) - home raid 5 (2) - drobo and encryption (2) - home raid array (2) - drobo 2 (2) - drobo open source alternative (2) - drobo log file encrypted (1) - does drobo work with ssds? (1) - hack drobopro (1) - centos drobopro (1) - nas raid drobo (1) - home raid drive special (1) - drobo raid technology (1) - drobo pro or raid (1) - hack drobo software (1) - centos timecapsule (1) - networked drobo alternatives (1) - how to create raid array like drobo (1) - use drobo on solaris (1) - reasons to upgrade from drobo to drobo pro (1) - hacking the drobopro (1) - drobo vs raid nas (1) - drobo pro hacks (1) - what raid configuration is best for home users (1) - drobo raid modes (1) - drovo pro for home (1) - best raid configuration for home users (1) - setting up drobo centos (1) - drobo pro full performance (1) - drobo network alternative (1) -
Thanks for the great summary – I am really lusting after the Drobo now. I do video and photography and I’m juggling a bunch of big external drives. It’s silly, really. NewEgg has 2 different 1 TB drives for $150.
I bit the bullet on the Drobo when they released the Firewire version and dropped the USB 2.0 to $350. Right now I’m running 2x 750ig, 1x 500 gig, and 1x 1 tera in mine, giving me a little over 2 terabytes of total storage.
It is freaking incredible. It is sometimes a bit slow, but for holding ALL of my pics and my music collection…well, I’m never using anything else if I can help it. I’m considering getting a second next year to set up at my parents house for offsite redundancy, but for simple onsite backup, it is seriously like magic.
[...] » Sweet Drobo Home RAID MaisonBisson.com (tags: drobo raid) [...]
Actually, Robin Harris quite likes the Drobo, since it is _not_ a RAID solution and also manages to hide most of the replication and redundancy stuff from the user: http://blogs.zdnet.com/storage/?p=117.
One of his points against home RAID remains valid, though. Drobo still protects you only against hard drive failure and little else.
[...] been a fan of Drobo since I got mine over a year ago. The little(-ish, and sweet looking, for stack of disks) device [...]