There are so many cool things in Fred Stutzman’s recent post, but this point rang the bell for me just as I was considering the differences between World of Warcraft and Second Life. More on those games in a moment, first let’s get Stutzman’s description of ego vs. object networks:
An ego-centric social network places the individual as the core of the network experience (Orkut, Facebook, LinkedIn, Friendster) while the object-centric network places a non-ego element at the center of the network. Examples of object-centric networks include Flickr (social object: photograph), Dopplr (social object: travel instance), del.icio.us (social object: hyperlink) and Digg (social object: news item).
But how are they really different?
the problem with ego-centric networks lies in the fact network-reestablishment is the main chore. Talk to individuals joining Facebook today - what are they doing? They’re using inbox importers and searching to find their friends/ex-classmates/etc. It’s a game, it’s fun for a bit, but then (say it with me readers) “What’s next?” Yes, the what’s next moment occurs. This is not to say the network becomes useless: no, it’s very useful rolodex, and the newsfeeds introduce concepts of peripheral participation (or social surveillance), but the game is in essence over.
All of this relates to World of Warcraft (WoW) and Second Life (SL) in that WoW offers the framework of a game, with new items to be found and new quests to be explored. WoW is a social experience, to be sure, but it centers on those quests. SL, on the other hand, is “a 3-D virtual world entirely created by its Residents.” Thing is, who can argue with this statement: “MySpace is a 2-D virtual world entirely created by its residents.”
I’m technically amused and interested in the affordances SL offers for remixing the experience, and some users have demonstrated that it could become object based, as Stutzman uses the term. But, for now, I’d argue that it’s a far more ego-centric experience. People pay to participate in SL, so it’s unlikely that people make a mass exodus as MySpace users have, but what’s driving outsiders to join?
I’ll admit that I’m the guy who long ago praised the description of IM as “all the interruptions of a phone call with all the frustrations of typing,” (though I can’t remember where I read the quote), and now I describe it as an essential business tool. As a realtime distance ed environment SL can’t be beat, and I can imagine something like a chemistry lecture where the instructor brings in 3-D models of various compounds, highlighting elements during a short lecture, then students highlighting other elements (or bringing in other compounds) during their questions. I just can’t imagine another reason for me spend time there, though, as always, I reserve the right to change my opinion.
Posted November 7, 2007 by Casey Bisson
Categories: Technology. Tags: ego, fred stutzman, mmorpg, second life, social network, social networking, social software, world of warcraft, WOW.
1 Comment(s)
Comments RSS
TrackBack Identifier URI
Leave a comment
User contributed tags for this post:
orkutsex (23) - www.wow.sex (14) - www.lifesex.com (11) - www.wow sex.com (9) - object (8) - lifesex.com (5) - wow game object (5) - sl sex clips (5) - Wow Game objects (5) - www.orkutsex.com (5) - geo tv com (4) - sl.sex.com (4) - EGO SEX com (4) - www.sl sex.com (4) - www.hotsex video.com (4) - game object wow (4) - wow objects (3) - cool wow objects (3) - www.arabsextv.com (3) - site:maisonbisson com www geo tv com (3) - ebn video.com (3) - orkutsexvideo (3) - www.ebn video.com (3) - sl sex vedio (3) - arabsextv (3) - life sex vedio (3) - wow object (3) - wow object list (3) - ego-based (3) - social object (3) - www.world sex.com (3) - www.geo.tv.com (3) - WWW GEO TV COM (3) - ebnvideo (2) - orkutsex.com (2) - wow sex.com (2) - wow pono sex (2) - link:http://www worldofwarcraft com/ inurl:blog (2) - world of warcraft object (2) - www.sl.sex.com (2) - facebook and ego (2) - object of social network (2) - www.sl school sex.com (2) - object based social networking (2) - world of warcraft sex.com (2) - orkut sex.com (2) - cool Game objects WoW (2) - www.sex life (2) - www.lifesex (2) - wow game object list (2) - second life ebn (2) - www.arabsextv (2) - second life freebies (2) - ego social network (2) - sl sex.com (2) - world of warcraft vs second life (2) - geotv.life (2) - verboten sex (2) - sex vedio (2) - orkut.sex.com (2) - ebn-video.com (2) - elephantsex (2) - 2nd life vs wow (2) - www,lifesex,com (2) - www.s.l.sex.com (2) - wow sex vedio (2) - orkut sex vedio (2) - secondlife crack object (2) - www.orkutsex.com.in (1) - orkut sex video.com (1) - object game for wow\ (1) - warcarft vs ben10 (1) - blog de game object wow (1) - www.orkutsex (1) - orkut.sex movies (1) - WoW game object search (1) - WoW vs Second Life (1) - world of warcraft game object browser (1) - wow objects i'd (1) - wow objekte liste (1) - evil object wow (1) - crack objet sl (1) - ego social network game (1) - www.lifesex.com.in (1) - vedio EBN sex (1) - games as social objects (1) - www//hotsex games (1) - object numbers for wow (1) - wow statistics social (1) - sexe tv lifi arab (1) - www.arab sexs wow (1) - cool game objects world of warcraft (1) - sl social network (1) - sexe lifi arab (1) - www.lifesex,com (1) - object based networks (1) - orkut vedio sex.com (1) - داستانهای مامانی ir (1) - orkut sexvedio (1) - object-centric social networks (1) - orkut vedio sex (1) - join two objects on sl (1) - non ego object (1) - sexe lifi arab tv (1) - wow cool game object (1) - Liste Game Object wow (1) - wow cool objects (1) - join 2 objects in second life (1) - www/lifesex.com (1) - World Of Warcraft objects (1) - orkut ebn (1) - www arabsextv.com (1) - OBJECT MUSIC SOCIAL NETWORKING (1) - www.ebn-video.com (1) - Gameobjects wow (1) - object centric social networks (1) - WoW Object Manage (1) - www lifesex.com (1) - ebn.video.com (1) - object wow (1) - www.hotsex/video.com (1) - game Objects für WoW (1) - object list to wow all (1) - game objects bei wow (1) - sex lifi arabic tv (1) - object item list wow (1) - fun gameobject wow (1) - orkut.sex (1) - 89 com (1) - second life sex com (1) - EBN Second live (1) - bluetooth social networking second life (1) - 10 vs 1 wow (1) - video social object (1) - ebn virtual worlds (1) - EGO based people (1) - social networking ego (1) - wow www(89 com (1) - My Network Places 89 com video (1) - the social life in WoW (1) - ???? ir (1) - SecondLife criticism (1) - sex 1 wow (1) - Object to object email second life (1) - object-based social networks (1) - hetero cyclic compounds (1) - ego based networks (1) - social networks facebook linkedin ego (1) - object based social network (1) - life sex com (1) -
“People pay to participate in SL”
No. They don’t.
Like most services they can pay tier fees to “own” land, but anymore I see very few people whose payment information is on file. Very few.
I suspect a fair number “rent” instead, using money they acquire *inside* Second Life; but very likely many more are virtual squatters who acquire freebies to outfit their avatar and never pay a dime to anyone… real or virtual.