First They Ignore You, Then They Ridicule You, Then They Fight You

Railroads once defined our transportation infrastructure...

It’s an aside to Kathryn Greenhill’s larger point, that all this 2.0 stuff is about a shifting power to the user, but she places L2 somewhere on Ghandi’s continuum of change between ridicule and fight.

The photo above (original by Monster) is in support of Greenhill’s larger point: control is shifting. Trains were once seen as icons of freedom, but that view changed with the development of the automobile — and the way it shifted control of routes and schedules from the railroad to the driver.

We’ve been arguing transportation policy for a long time since, but here’s a simple fact: railroads didn’t realize they were competing against automobiles until it was too late.

Who are you competing against?

libraries, lib20, l2, library 2.0, competition, control, railroads vs. automobiles, change, locus of control

Related:

6 Comments

  1. Comment by Kathryn Greenhill on September 12, 2007 8:26 pm

    Ah ! Ghandi. Thank you so much. I read this quote in the early 90’s, and since then could never quite get the wording right when I searched to find the origin. I was trying things like “evolution of ideas”.

    I think the piece I read back in the early 90’s actually took this quote and applied it to the evolution of ideas. I’ll have to hunt it down - as I have a better lead now - thanks.

    So - does this analogy make you and John and Dave on a par with the drivers of the first Model T’s ?

  2. Comment by Casey on September 13, 2007 1:55 am

    @Kathryn:

    You just inspired me to again look for lessons about the future of libraries based on the history of transportation (I’m open to other fields too, transportation is just so convenient lately). It turns out I might rather be Edsel Ford.

  3. Pingback by » Lessons In Change From Ford Motor Company on September 13, 2007 12:49 pm

    [...] competition and change management, but just as I figured I was done with it for the week, a comment from Kathryn Greenhill regarding Model Ts got me going [...]

  4. Pingback by Library Views ????? :: Library 2.0 ?????? :: September :: 2007 on September 23, 2007 12:47 pm

    [...] Casey Bisson 則以鐵路曾經是自由的象徵,但後來被汽車所取代的例子來支持 Greenhill 關於 “control is shifting” 的看法。 [...]

  5. Pingback by » Internet Librarian 2007 Presentation: Building Web 2.0 Native Library Services on October 31, 2007 1:48 pm

    [...] slides for my main talk are online in Quicktime and PDF format. Extra: how the steam engine relates to all this. Related:Organizational/Institutional Blogging Done RightLate Notes From October Library [...]

  6. Comment by mojtaba on June 21, 2008 9:10 am

    hello.

Comments RSS TrackBack Identifier URI

Leave a comment

 

User contributed tags for this post:

??? ?? ????? (68) - ?? ?????? (62) - ?? ????? (48) - mss (45) - ?????? ???? (39) - ?????? ????? (35) - ?????? ?? ? ????? (30) - ????????? ????? (30) - داستانsexi (24) - ????? (22) - ???????? ???? (22) - داستانهای مامانی (22) - ?????? ?? ??????? (21) - ??????sexi (20) - ?????? ??? ?? ????? (20) - سكسسي (18) - ?????? ?? ????? (17) - ?? ? ?????? (17) - ?????? ??? ????? (17) - ?????? ?? ? ?????? (16) - ?? ? ????? (16) - ?????? ?? ?????? (16) - ?????? sexi (15) - ???? ?? ?????? (15) - ????????? ?? ? ?????? (15) - ????????? ?? ? ????? (15) - ????????? ???? ?? ????? (14) - ??????s (14) - ???? ?? ????? (13) - ?????? (13) - داستان من ومامان (13) - ??? ?? ?????? (13) - سکسسی (12) - من ومامان (12) - ????????? ?? ?????? (12) - داستان مامان (12) - ?? ??????? (11) - ??? ????? (11) - ?????? ???? ?? ????? (11) - داستانs (11) - www.شهوت سرا.com (10) - first they ridicule you (10) - http://www google com/search (10) - ?????? ??? (10) - first they ignore you (10) - ??? ??????? (10) - ????????? ???? ????? (9) - ????????? ?? ??????? (9) - ??????? (9) - ?? ?? ????? (9) - ????????? ???? (9) - ??? ????? 3 (9) - ?????? ??? ?? ?????? (9) -  (9) - ?????? ??? ?????? (8) - ????????? (8) - داستان مامانی (8) - first they fight you (7) - داستانهای سکسی من ومامان (7) - ????????? ?????? (7) - داستان سكسسي (7) - ?????? s (7) - First they ignore you; then they ridicule you; then the (6) - ????????? ?? ? (6) - ????? ???? (6) - ?????? ????????? (6) - ????????? SEXI (6) - ????????? ?? (6) - ?????? ???? ?? ? ????? (6) - true (6) - first they ridicule (6) - first they ignore you ghandi (5) - ?????? ???? ?? ?????? (5) - ?? ? ?? ?????? (5) - ماجراهاي سكسي (5) - من ومامانم (5) - %D8%B3%D9%83%D8%B3 %D9%85%D9%86 %D9%88%D9%85%D8%A7%D9%8 (5) - ?????? ?? (5) - first they ignore you then they fight you (5) - ghandi quotes (5) - ?? ?? ?????? (4) - ?????? ??? ?? ??????? (4) - ???? (4) - ????????? ??? ?????? (4) - http://www google com/custom (4) - داستان سکس با مامان (4) - ????????? ???? ?? ? ????? (4) - ???????? ??? (4) - ?????? ???? pdf (4) - سكس بامامان (4) - ??? ?? (4) - ???? ??????? (4) - ???????? ?? ? ????? (4) - ???? ??? com (4) - بامامان (4) - داستان سکسسی (4) - ????????? ???? ?? ?????? (3) - first they ignore you then they ridicule you ghandi quo (3) - ??? ?? ?? ?????? (3) - ?????? ??? ??????? (3) - ?? ?????? ???? (3) - ?????? ???? ?? ?? ?????? (3) - سکس با مامان (3) - داستانهاي ماماني (3) - ??? ?? ? ????? (3) - ?????? ????? ? ?? (3) - داستان من و مامان (3) - ??? ?? ?? ??? (3) - ????? pdf (3) - ????????? s (3) - ????????? ??? (3) - داستان sexi (3) - ?????? ??? ?? ? ????? (3) - ??????s pdf (3) - ??? (3) - ?????? ?? ??? (3) - داستانهای سکسیمامان (3) - سکس من ومامان (3) - ?????? ???? ?? (3) - ?????? ????1 (3) - pdf ?? ?????? (3) - ماجراهاي من ومامانم (2) - داستان سكس بامامان (2) - ????????? ???? ?? ? ?????? (2) - ?????? ???? ?? ??????? (2) - داستان سكس (2) - داستان سكس با مامانم (2) - داستانهاي سكسسي (2) - First they ignore you Video (2) - سكس من ومامان (2) - ???????? ?? (2) - sexi داستان (2) - داستان من ومامانم (2) - داستانهای مامان جون (2) - first they ignore you then (2) - داستانهای من ومامانم (2) - Ghandi first they fight you (2) - داستانهای من و مامان (2) - ridicule fight (2) -