I was honored to be a panelist at the LITA/ALCTS CCS Authority Control in the Online Environment Interest Group presentation of “Authority Control Meets Faceted Browse.”
What is faceting? Why is it (re)emerging in use? Where can I see it in action? This program is intended to introduce the audience to facet theory, showcase implementations that use faceted approaches for online catalogs, and facilitate discussion on the relationship between structured authority data and this type of navigation.
Kathryn La Barre of University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign explained the theory, while NCSU’s Charley Pennel, Vanderbilt’s Mary Charles Lasater, and I each described its implementation in Endeca, Primo, and Scriblio respectively. Scriblio is an open source project that has less than one FTE working on it, so it’s an honor to see it compared against commercial offerings, especially NCSU’s groundbreaking work.
My slides are online in QuickTime and PDF form, and I was proud to be able to show off the new public beta of the Lamson Library website and catalog, based on Scriblio.
I should be careful to point out that faceting is a theory of cataloging and classification, while clustering is the technical process of aggregating and reporting relevant metadata in search and browse screens. The difference is that Scriblio doesn’t impose rules on our cataloging practice, it simply supports clustering the metadata to make it easier to find the resources we’re looking for.
If anything, the importance of authority control increases in faceted/clustered search and browse systems, but it is a matter of exchanging one set of technological constraints for another. Card catalogs, with their alphabetical access and physical affordances (or limitations) demanded cataloging practice that is in some ways at odds with the very different affordances and limitations of faceted/clustered search and browse.
Among current implementations, clustering does well with subjects, but poorly with authors. Looking at the cardinality of those facets, it’s easy to understand the problem:
(statistics from the Lamson Library (beta) catalog.)
The number of unique authors compared to the number of total authors is very high, while a large number of subjects are represented by a small number of unique headings. Still, some authors are well suited to faceted browse, and their emergence in a result set could be mined to help users further refine their searches. Example: J. K. Rowling is an obvious top author in searches for both “harry potter” and “j k rowling”. Her statistical “pop” in the results might be worth looking at and worth leveraging elsewhere.
As currently implemented, however, clustered results most help the user who doesn’t know the proper terms for her field of interest. A user searching “sociology of education” is likely to be interested in materials cataloged under “educational sociology,” and clustered search navigation works well in that and similar circumstances.
clustering, faceting, faceted search and browse, authority control, library, library 2.0 lib20, libraries, Scriblio, presentation, LITA, ALCTS
Posted June 27, 2007 by Casey Bisson
Categories: Libraries & Networked Information, Technology. Tags: alcts, authority control, clustering, faceted search and browse, faceting, libraries, library, library 2.0 lib20, LITA, presentation, scriblio.
4 Comments
Comments RSS
TrackBack Identifier URI
User contributed tags for this post:
faceted (39) - scriblio (26) - faceted browsing (21) - wordpress faceted (15) - faceted browse (14) - faceted search mysql (14) - collective intelligence limitation (12) - faceted search tutorial (12) - faceting (11) - faceted search wordpress (10) - mysql facets (10) - www.urdunews.com (10) - mysql faceted search (10) - Authority Control Meets Faceted Browse (9) - importance of authority control (9) - WWW.ART ONLIN.COM (7) - mysql faceted (7) - faceted searching (5) - faceted browsing php (5) - facet search vs cluster (5) - scriblio facets (5) - faceted search library (5) - mysql faceted browsing (4) - primo catalogue facets (4) - wordpress faceted search (4) - 18 post com (4) - wordpress faceted browsing (4) - scriblio tutorial (4) - faceted search for websites? (4) - faceted search presentation (3) - faceted browsing tag cloud (3) - faceted search implementation in php (3) - Faceted Search Library Website (3) - searching faceting (3) - wordpress faceted search plugin (3) - wordpress plugin faceted search (3) - iPhone faceted search (3) - facets mysql (3) - php faceted (3) - iphone facets (3) - facet browsing (3) - scriblio faceted (3) - php facets (3) - faceting and libraries (3) - Authority Control Faceted (3) - faceted classification wordpress plugin (3) - faceted search php (3) - wordpress facets (3) - faceted search mysql php (3) - faceted mysql (3) - php faceted search (3) - scriblio faceted search (3) - scriblio search not working (3) - facet search PHP (2) - tagged metadata for faceted search (2) - primo and facets (2) - faceted results presentation (2) - www.geo urdunews.com (2) - iphone faceted navigation (2) - www.18.post.com (2) - open source faceted search (2) - clustering versus tagging (2) - php faceted browsing (2) - mysql faceting (2) - www.18 post.com (2) - difference between faceted search and clustered (2) - library 2.0 faceted searching (2) - facets authors (2) - faceted plugin wordpress (2) - faceted library classification examples (2) - primo facets (2) - php facet search (2) - faceted search wikipedia (2) - urdunews,com (2) - faceted browsing wordpress (2) - iphone faceted (2) - facets browse (2) - what difference between faceted clustered searching (2) - library catalog facets (2) - searching and browsing library (2) - endeca scriblio (2) - apple facetted browsing example (2) - faceted search open source (2) - facets of intelligence (2) - search plugin facets wordpress (2) - tutoriel faceted search (2) - faceted navigation open source php (2) - geo.urdunews.com (2) - wikipedia faceting (2) - faceted search explained wikipedia (2) - faceted search iphone (2) - scriblio search (2) - facet browsing php (2) - primo faceted (2) - www.geo.urdunews.com (2) - Facetted search for wikipedia (2) - faceting clustering (2) - google faceted search, (2) - online catalogs faceted searching (2) - google faceted browsing (2) - faceted search php tutorial (2) - faceted searching open source (2) - urdunews (2) - faceted search catalog (2) - cache zLMTEwh9wmkJ litablog org 2007 06 28 authority co (2) - bisson faceting and clustering (2) - authority control faceted browse (2) - faceted results (2) - Faceted Searching and Browsing (2) - clustering faceting (2) - faceted browsing and navigation in websites la barre (2) - faceted search wordpress plugin (2) - what is faceting (2) - faceted search plugin for wordpress (2) - faceted searching library catalogs (2) - search 2 0 endeca (2) - difference between facets and clustering (2) - Faceted navigation PHP MYSQL (2) - ubuntu linux faceted navigation (2) - metasearching clustering and facets (2) - facet of intelligence (2) - what is scriblio (2) - Dragonflyer X6 illinois (2) - faceting php tutorial (2) - faceting searching (2) - clustered searching library catalog (2) - mysql faceted navigation (2) -
[...] Faceted Searching and Browsing in Scriblio, at the LITA/ALCTS CCS Authority Control in the Online Environment Interest Group presentation of “Authority Control Meets Faceted Browse.†[...]
The metasearch products shown @ ALA are also embracing not only faceting, but clustering (automatic creation of facets). I made a small report of those products over at http://janusman.wordpress.com/2007/06/27/metasearching-ala/
[...] Casey Bisson – Presentation: Faceted Searching and Browsing in Scriblio [...]
[...] librarians’ subject guides listed at or near the top to help you out. You can also use the facets, clustered metadata shown in the right sidebar that reflect the aggregated results of that [...]