Vonage will be in court again tomorrow defending itself against Verizon’s claims of patent infringement. The innovative VoIP company had lost the trial and was ordered to pay $58 Million in damages in early March, when a jury found them to have violated thee of seven related patents held by Verizon. Vonage appealed of course, but it’s uncertain if the company, which has yet to turn a profit, has the stamina for a drawn out battle. The company’s annual 10-K filing painted a stark picture of the challenges Vonage faces (NPR coverage).

The best news for Vonage so far came on April 6, when an appeals court temporarily lifted the injunction that would have forced them to cease operations. And tomorrow the company will face an appeals court in a case that could make or break the company.

I’m among those that’s been saying patent law is broken, and cases like this are a perfect illustration of how laws that were meant to encourage innovation are instead used to protect the establishment. (Take a look at Article I Section 8, where it speaks of promoting “the progress of science and useful arts.”)

The Software Freedom Law Center’s Eben Moglen says Verizon filed for the patents in 1997 specifically so that it could use them as ammunition against the then developing but not commercialized VoIP technology.

vonage, verizon, intellectual property, patent infringement, patent law, lawsuit, court case, legal battle, innovation, chilling effect, underdog, copyfight

Posted April 23, 2007 by Casey Bisson
Categories: Copyrights & Intellectual Property, Politics & Controversy, Technology. Tags: chilling effect, copyfight, court case, innovation, intellectual property, lawsuit, legal battle, patent infringement, patent law, underdog, verizon, vonage.

1 Comment(s)

Comments RSS TrackBack Identifier URI

Leave a comment

Name (required)

Mail (will not be published) (required)

Website

 

User contributed tags for this post:

patent cost (18) - vonage copyright (17) - cost of innovation (12) - vonage (10) - bibliochaise cost (9) - bibliochaise price (7) - cost of a patent (7) - *67 vonage (5) - high cost of innovation (4) - vonage patents (4) - vonage patent (4) - cost of patent (4) - patent costs (3) - *67 cost verizon (3) - vonage cost (3) - patents high prices? (3) - vonage patent infringement (3) - *67 on Vonage (2) - vonage costs 2004 (2) - vonage high cost (2) - cost patent (2) - Vonage innovations (2) - cost of vonage (2) - vonage 10-k (2) - high cost patent litigation (2) - high cost innovation (2) - the cost of a patent (2) - www/sixs/sat (2) - verizon vonage patents (2) - vonage test site (2) - verizon vonage patent (2) - vonage and patent (2) - vonage innovation (2) - innovation cost (2) - vonage controversy (2) - cost innovation is high (1) - vonage 10-K 2004 (1) - www sixs sat tv (1) - voip patent woes (1) - bibliochaise prices (1) - cost of bibliochaise (1) - sixs89 (1) - vonage *67 (1) - vonage patents 2008 (1) - vonage patent infringement cost (1) - cost for patent (1) - Cost of K patent (1) - cost of infringement case (1) - infringement cost (1) - web design vonage (1) - cost of innovation example (1) - vonage court case 2008 (1) - Vonage *67 cost (1) - cost of defending patent infringement cases (1) - innovations patents costs (1) - the costs of innovation (1) - cost patent infringement (1) - vonage costs (1) - Verizon 676 patent (1) - vonage npr (1) - what is the cost of innovation (1) - Vonage Court Case (1) - patent litigation high cost (1) - Bibliochaise (1) - the cost of patents high (1) - Verizon and innovation (1) - Verizon s patent claims (1) - technology patent cost (1) - vonage patent march OR april (1) - cache EwL5xeLPzAEJ maisonbisson com blog search h 323 v (1) - vonage and innovation (1) - vonage court case september (1) - Vonage s patent laws (1) - The high cost of innovation (1) - vonage patent january (1) - high cost of patent litigation (1) - www.sixs 89 (1) - innovation are the high costs (1) - high price of innovation (1) - high cost patent (1) - biggest cost of innovation (1) - 67 vonage (1) - cost of using *67 on vonage (1) - Cost of Innovation at Google (1) - high pricing innovations (1) - innovation cease patent law (1) - the high price of innovation (1) - mss (1) - 4 Vonage (1) -