Annalee Newitz last week posted a column on people’s fear of privacy loss as a result of Google Maps. Her point:
So while all these people are wringing their hands over how simple it is for strangers to discover the color of their roof on Google, we forget that we can already be tracked everywhere we go using cell phones and the RFID chips in Wal-Mart backpacks.
I honestly didn’t know people were up in arms about the maps and satellite images (which have been available elsewhere for years), and, like Annalee, I’m much more concerned about the proliferation of real-time tracking systems like cameras, RFID tags in our driver’s licenses and consumer products, and other sensor technologies.
And that’s why, while I think Google Maps reinvention of online mapping services is the best thing since push-pops, I’m a little cautious about Google Lab’s Ridefinder, which shows real-time positions of taxi cabs and shuttle vans in a few metropolitan areas. Google’s satellite images show a snapshot in time, often from many months ago (longer maybe, in the case of the low-res rural areas), but these pins in a map that update with the push of a button are a real. There’s a vehicle on the ground in DC moving fairs around town, and I can see it on screen. All Google is showing us is the vehicle positioning data they get from the operators, but it also serves to remind us that the operators could probably offer their dispatching details too (2am pick up at Washington Regent Hotel, drop at Columbus and 4th). That’s scarier yet.
On the other hand, The Map Room and The Importance Of… point out another way to put pins in a map: ChicagoCrime.org uses publicly available police blotter data to show crime info on a Google Map of the city. The stats show “simple batter” was the most commonly reported crime type, and the map shows the past 50 incidents to be pretty evenly distributed through the city. Arson threats seem to be concentrated in the area between 290 and 94, and in to the south of the city, arson itself is somewhat more widely distributed.
Like the the day Google Maps added satellite images, I found myself lost in exploration in ChicagoCrime.org’s crime maps. But these maps also show what is becoming Google Maps’ real legacy: to make GIS tools available to a wider audience. As more people start building hacks applications based these tools, we’ll find some that give reasonable people cause for privacy concern, and others that amaze us with utility (without making us give up our privacy).
Then I go back to Annalee’s point: at least we can see what information Google has on is in their maps and satellite images. At least we can watch the watchers. Other, more obscure data sources may be no better protected against misuse, even while they collect more detailed data about who we are and what we do.
Related:
Posted May 20, 2005 by Casey
Categories: Technology. .
4 Comments
Comments RSS
TrackBack Identifier URI
Leave a comment
User contributed tags for this post:
google heart (11764) - google heart com (5814) - heart google (3405) - download google heart (1952) - google (1922) - Google Earth com (1293) - google heart satellite (1089) - google hearts (777) - google crime map (618) - google earth map (604) - google map satelite (522) - Google Earth Maps 81 (471) - google heart map (462) - gogle heart (455) - google crime images (332) - google eart map (282) - google maps crime (204) - download google eart (186) - heart de google (181) - heart maps (170) - eart map (158) - google eart (154) - heart (148) - GOGLE MAP (146) - google erth satellite (137) - heart satellite (129) - heart google map (111) - HEART FROM SATELITE (108) - all (107) - heart gogle (105) - google heart italiano (93) - download (92) - map satelite (81) - google heart in italiano (79) - google crime (79) - gogle heart com (77) - download google heart italiano (74) - google hearts satellite (74) - map google heart (65) - google heart 2005 (65) - maps heart (64) - google google heart (60) - download google earth italiano (59) - google heart photo satellitaire (57) - satellite google (55) - google eart download (52) - heart satelite (48) - google eart program download (47) - satellite google heart (45) - gogle earth map (44) - dowload google heart (43) - gogle earth (43) - hearth satellite (42) - download google heart in italiano (41) - WWW GOOGLE HEART COM (40) - gogle co hu (40) - heart gogle satelite (38) - gogle hearts (37) - gogle come (37) - map heart google (36) - google eart maps (34) - WWW GOOGLE HEART (33) - google eart watch view from satellite camera (33) - heart google com (30) - gogle maps (30) - google earth italiano (29) - satelite google (29) - satellite gogle (28) - google around earth com (28) - google eart downloaden (28) - google map heart (28) - googleheart (27) - heart google satellite (27) - Downlaod google heart (27) - google earth globe digital (26) - satellite (26) - google eart satelite (26) - google heart image satellite (25) - gogle eart (25) - google eart in italiano (24) - google earth crime maps (24) - google eart without downloading (24) - heart map google (24) - GEOGLE EART (23) - download google heart satellite (23) - mapa google heart (23) - gogle satellite (23) - HEART GOOGLE MAPS (22) - heart google download italiano (21) - gogle eart map (21) - google earth com in italiano (21) - DC crime map (20) - google earth co il (20) - heart download satellite (20) - heart image satelite (20) - google map chernobyl (20) - google heart maps (19) - download google eart map (19) - download di googleheart (18) - gogle earth satellite (18) - realtime satelite images (18) - gogle and satelite image (18) - image satellite google heart (18) - dowload google eart (18) - google earth portugal (17) - google earth realtime satelite (17) - geogle hearts (17) - eart maps (17) - gogle hearts com (17) - download google eart and see people moving (16) - photo satellite google heart (16) - Realtime Satelite Photos (16) - crime map google (16) - google heart com in italiano (15) - download google heart com (15) - Google Earth crime (15) - map eart (15) - satellite heart google (15) - satelite gogle (14) - earth com satellite (14) - map gogle (14) - heart google image (14) - sex co il (14) - googl hearts (14) - google map of chernobyl (14) - satelite GOOGLE HEART (14) - hearts google com (13) - google digital satelite photos (13) - heart e google (13) - gogle eart in italiano (13) - gogle satellite maps (13) - image satellite gogle (13) - google erth gis (13) - googleheart italiano (13) - map googleheart (13) - gogle AND heart (13) - WWW HEART GOOGLE (12) - WWW GOOGLE EART (12) - Google earth com in (12) - gogle earth com (12) - maps google heart (12) - satelite view heart (12) - satellite googleheart (12) - download google hearts (12) - googl eart map (11) - download gogle maps (11) - eart sat (11) - maps heart google (11) - google earth homeland security privacy (11) - maps eart (11) -
good
salve scusatemi per il disturbo ma non so come poter chiedere e a chi chiedere un vostro servizio.
come vedete sono italiano , a me serve una scansione dal satellite in un a date precisa in una coordinata precisa ad un ora precisa. vi spiego, voglio scoprire la dinamica di un incidente stradale dove ho perso mia madre emio nipote di soli 4 anni potete darmi una mano? grazie arrivederci
[...] What’s my reticence? I don’t know if I should have this data…and putting it together like this hits my privacy funny bone a bit. But then, this data exists…it’s a matter of public record. And I think I rather that everybody have it than only a few. [...]
i like to see live satelite image how do i do that