Richard Coniff writes in the January 2004 Smithsonian magazine about the work of UC San Fran prof Paul Ekman and his study of faces. It carries pictures of a work by artists Bill Viola and his wife Kira Perov.
Yeah, sure, the face is capable of 43 movements expressing 10,000 different expressions. Yeah, Bill’s work is interesting, but…
I have two complaints. First, there’s all this talk that facial expressions are confusing. Ekman’s work presents the expressions out of context for a second or less at a time. Oh my, how surprising that they mistake anger for disgust! Ekman tells us that it’s all in the nose (it’s scrunched up for disgust). And sure, surprise looks like fear, but with an open mouth, but isn’t there something foolish about suggesting that we’re bad at reading faces because the students usually goof half the expressions? What about context? Again, let me ask: WHAT ABOUT CONTEXT?
The fault is probably more with the writer’s gloss or un-nuanced delivery than with Ekman’s studies. Clearly the author didn’t have much room to maneuver in six paragraphs, a caption and a pull quote, and clearly, there wouldn’t be much to the story if the author suggested “but people are actually much better at understanding expressions in context, because, as it turns out, there’s a whole lot more to it that the angle of the brow.”
My second (real) complaint (and aint I full of complaints?(and appositives)) is that Viola’s work (which removes, ignores, or alters context for the sake of art) is such a knock-off. Let me introduce you to Human-InToFace, the somewhat less celebrated exploration of the face, its expressions and it’s connection to the person.
Posted June 6, 2004 by Casey Bisson
Categories: Books, Movies, Music. .
2 Comments
Comments RSS
TrackBack Identifier URI
User contributed tags for this post:
ekman faces (489) - free faces of death pics (256) - ekman face (82) - ekman test (61) - paul ekman video (57) - ekman pictures (53) - ekman 60 faces test (53) - paul ekman biography (49) - kira perov (43) - Ekman photos (37) - ekman video (35) - pictures of faces (31) - Paul Ekman pictures (30) - Paul Ekman face reading (29) - eckman faces (26) - EKMAN IMAGES (24) - paul ekman torrent (23) - paul ekman faces (22) - FACE EXPRESSIONS PICTURES (22) - Ekman faces test (20) - reading faces Ekman (19) - reading faces (19) - paul ekman facial expressions images (18) - ekman face pictures (18) - paul ekman photos (18) - faces pictures (18) - paul ekman test (18) - ekman faces pictures (18) - expressions pics (17) - richard coniff (16) - faces of death pics (16) - criticism of Paul Ekman (15) - www.xxl love.com (14) - Ekman 60 Faces (13) - paul eckman (13) - expression pics (13) - faces pics (13) - ekman photographs (12) - paul ekman quotes (12) - deathpics (12) - faces photos (12) - the Ekman 60 faces test (12) - ekman fear (11) - ekman face reading (11) - Eckman face reading (11) - Paul Ekman Photo (11) - paul ekman (10) - pictures of face expressions (10) - pictures of faces with different expressions (10) - ekman faces images (10) - pics of faces (10) - paul ekman images (9) - Expressions pictures (9) - faces ekman (9) - ekman face test (9) - bad faces pictures (9) - eckman face (9) - ekman reading faces (8) - ekman faces fear (8) - ekman face images (8) - faces expressions pictures (8) - read paul ekman online free (8) - face expressions pics (7) - ekman faces picture (7) - Ekman face picture (7) - pic of faces (7) - ekman facial (7) - expressions faces (7) - facial expressions pics (7) - bad faces photos (7) - expressive faces (7) - ekman photo (7) - faces photographs (6) - Paul Ekman face reader AND pictures (6) - free faces of death pics video (6) - pictures of faces with expressions (6) - facial expression pictures (6) - paul ekman pics (6) - scrunched up face pictures (6) - pics of expressions (6) - funny faces pics (6) - study of faces (6) - anger pics (5) - faces of disgust (5) - Ekman faces photographs (5) - Paul Ekman 7 Faces (5) - paul ekman photographs (5) - paul ekman face reading pictures (5) - Ekman 60 (5) - www pictures love com (5) - paul ekman face photos (5) - eckman face test (5) - scrunched up faces (5) - reading faces pictures (5) - scrunched up face picture (5) - www pictures of love com (5) - ekman faces image (5) - different expression of faces pictures (5) - Reading Peoples Faces Ekman (4) - faces expressions (4) - funny faces.com (4) - paul ekman videos (4) - test ekman (4) - images of paul ekman (4) - expressive faces pictures (4) - facial reading in marketing (4) - critics of paul ekman (4) - paul ekman torrents (4) - ekman facial pictures (4) - ekman faces intellectual property (4) - ekman face photograph (4) - pictures of faces ekman (4) - download Ekman 60 Faces (4) - reading facial expressions pictures (4) - paul ekman picture (4) - pictures of expressive faces (4) - pictures of ekman faces (4) - ekman s faces (4) - ekman and faces (4) - ekman face video (4) - ekman anger (4) - face reading (4) - disgust ekman (3) - Eckman Faces Test (3) - picture of scrunched up face (3) - facial expressions pictures (3) -
[...] The thing about this is that it reminds me of Troy Bennett’s Human-IntoFace, reported here back in 2002 and 2004. [...]
Ekman’s work is not about those times when you have all the context and time in the world to read a face. It’s about when all you have is a split second. That’s his context. Like a cop suddenly faced with a potential suspect for whatever crime. The only way he’s going to decipher in a split second the difference between anger and fear and surprise and disgust etc. is if he’s practiced looking in detail at the subtle differences. He may only have a split second in which to make a life/death decision. Or take a juror trying to read a witness and the flash of a look that witness betrays before he/she composes him/herself. It’s about catching the deeper truth.